Vale’s Vargem Grande iron ore conveyor lagging problem

Vale-operated Vargem Grande mine site is located in the state of Minas Gerais, Brazil and contains 2.53 billion tonnes of proven and probable iron ore reserves, making it the world’s fourth biggest iron ore mining operation. The Vargem Grande site comprises three open-pits: Tamandua, Capitao do Mato and Aboboras.

Metso Brazil was working with the mine site as it was necessary to increase the service life of the lagging on a number of non-drive pulleys installed on a belt turn over conveyor. See FIG #1.

Severe localised belt wear was evident in as little as three months and the cost of conveyor downtime to replace the worn lagging was a serious problem. See FIG #2 & #3 below.

MetsoBrasil_Figure1

FIG #1

MetsoBrasil_Figure2
FIG #2

MetsoBrasil_Figure3_web
FIG #3

MetsoBrasil_Figure4_web

FIG #4

MetsoBrasil_Figure5_R

FIG #5

MetsoBrasil_Figure6

FIG #6

Initial attempts to address this problem by installing ceramic lagging in the high-wear areas fixed the lagging wear but transferred the high wear to the bottom belt cover. The steel cord ST3500 belt is a far more expensive component than the pulley lagging so the use of ceramic lagging was not a viable option. See FIG #4, #5 & #6.

Metso Brasil started looking for a lagging solution that would extend the service life past that of the rubber lagging and that wouldn’t cause wear on the conveyor belt covers. The Elastotec Polyurethane (PU) lagging was evaluated and considered a possible solution to this problem.

Two factors made the PU lagging an interesting option to increase the lagging service life:

1. PU has much higher abrasion resistance than rubber lagging. (DIN 53516 Abrasion Resistance Natural Rubber = 100mm3 volume loss vs. PU 35mm3 volume loss.)

2. PU has a much lower co-efficient of friction than rubber and this makes the surface slippery. The slippery surface allows the belt to slide over the PU lagging minimising any shear force that would cause wear.

An additional benefit of the slippery surface on the PU lagging is the resistance to build up of material from the dirty side of the belt.

Metso Brazil together with Elastotec came with a solution to trial the PU lagging on two non-drive pulleys, each having a diameter of 1250mm and a face width of 1600mm. Elastotec supplied 12mm diamond PU lagging in strips to suit the pulley face width. The PU lagging can also be supplied in rolls up to 85 metres long, but in this case strips were preferred. See FIG #7.

Elastotec supplied the PU lagging for both pulleys in December 2014. The lagging was manufactured with the Elastotec buffed CN bonding layer for cold vulcanised application. Metso applied the PU lagging onto the pulleys and in April 2015 the two pulleys were put into service. See FIG #8 & #9.

The PU lagging provided a service life increase from three months to 18 months compared to the lagging that was being used previously.

Vale maintenance personnel advised that in this environment a normal bend pulley that lasts one year would last at least three years with the PU lagging. Based on this result Vale is adding the Elastotec PU lagging to their general specification for all pulley applications with this type of operating conditions.

An additional benefit to the longer service life provided by the PU lagging has been the effect on the bottom cover of the steel cord belt where no additional wear has been observed. Given the high cost of steel cord belts this is possibly a greater cost saving than the extended life of the lagging.

Metso Brasil has been able to provide a solution to Vale’s lagging service life problems and sees this as an integral part of their role in helping their customers reduce conveyor operating costs and improve production performance.

MetsoBrasil_Figure7

FIG #7

MetsoBrasil_Figure8

FIG #8

MetsoBrasil_Figure9

FIG #9

For additional information on the application of PU lagging please contact:

David Molesworth
Sales Director,
Elastotec
Mobile: +61 (0)423 200 178
Email: david@elastotec.com.au
www.elastotec.com.au

Shane Scott
Operations Manager – Conveyor and
Lining Services, Metso Australia
Mobile: +61 (0)408 942 826
Email: shane.scott@metso.com
www.metso.com

Hugo Lemos
General Manager Product Support
Metso Brasil
Mobile:+1 599 789-9045
Email: huog.lemos@metso.com
www.metso.br